For Jeff Neese, the case for vocational horticulture begins with a high-school greenhouse in Indianapolis. Walking into the warm, humid, green space at Warren Central High School during an Indiana winter, he encountered a doorway that would shape his life. His argument is not that every student should skip college. It is that young people need an earlier, practical way to discover horticulture before they choose a career, and that commercial growers have a stake in providing it.
Neese credits two teachers, Phil Pitts and Pam Greene, with turning an interest into a career path. Pitts brought experience as a grower and landscape designer and set high expectations. Greene taught floriculture as part of the vocational program. Classes were not limited to memorizing plant names or growing a few plants for a spring fundraiser. Students were expected to understand plants and learn to grow them well. That meant confronting conditions that do not follow a school calendar: plants need water on weekends, pests and diseases do not wait for Monday, and crops respond to light, temperature, water and nutrition whether school is in session or not.
That experience gave Neese enough knowledge, experience and confidence to enter horticulture directly after high school. More than 40 years later, he is still in the industry. He does not diminish college education; the industry needs university-trained horticulturists, plant scientists, breeders, researchers and growers. But his path illustrates a point workforce discussions can miss: college should not be the first place a young person discovers horticulture, and a four-year degree should not be the only respected route into a professional horticulture career.
Start before the labor shortage
The industry, Neese writes, talks constantly about finding growers with practical production experience, planning for succession, recruiting college graduates and competing for a limited pool of talent. He argues that this conversation may start too late. Before asking where the next generation of growers will come from, the industry should ask where young people are supposed to encounter horticulture. A 15- or 16-year-old is unlikely to wake up one morning and decide greenhouse production sounds fascinating. Someone has to show them.
High-school vocational horticulture can therefore be important to the industry’s future. But a greenhouse behind a school is not enough by itself. A greenhouse is a living laboratory, and operating one takes knowledge, commitment and time. Agriculture teachers may cover broad subject areas; expecting each to be an accomplished greenhouse grower, crop scheduler, irrigation specialist, diagnostician, integrated pest management practitioner and environmental-control expert is not realistic. Nor should teachers be expected to develop all those skills alone.
Neese proposes that commercial greenhouse operations become active partners with local school greenhouses, not take over the teacher’s role or dictate curriculum. Growers could help develop an achievable crop plan and set realistic standards for irrigation, fertility, pH, EC, temperature and crop timing. They could walk the greenhouse with students and teach them how to scout rather than simply identify a plant’s problem. They could show how sticky cards are used, how roots are examined and how nutritional problems are diagnosed. They could also help teachers use existing equipment and give them someone knowledgeable to call when something goes wrong.
Internships show a snapshot, not the movie
Summer internships are valuable but insufficient on their own, the essay argues. For most high-school students, summer is the only extended period for full-time work, and that can provide a narrow view of greenhouse production. Depending on the operation, much of spring’s diversity and activity may be gone. Conditions are hot and humid. Because the students are inexperienced seasonal employees, they can end up doing whatever job nobody else particularly wants that day: sticking poinsettias, spacing crops, moving plants or cleaning houses.
Neese does not dismiss those tasks; they are part of commercial horticulture, and every good grower needs to understand the physical work involved. But if that is all a teenager experiences, greenhouse horticulture may not look exciting. The student has experienced greenhouse labor without necessarily experiencing greenhouse management.
To understand growing, students need to see how production changes through the year: fall crops and shortening days; winter’s lower light and humidity challenges; spring propagation and the controlled chaos of peak production; summer’s heat, irrigation demands and preparation for the next cycle. Each stage brings different crops, problems and decisions. An eight-week summer internship gives a student one snapshot; learning horticulture requires seeing the whole movie.
Neese wants school and commercial greenhouses to function as extensions of one another. If a participating grower understands what students are learning, the summer internship can become the next chapter of their education rather than an unrelated summer job. Students who have studied pH and EC could see how those are monitored commercially. Those learning scouting and IPM could join a crop walk with the person responsible for those programs. Those who have studied irrigation and fertility could see injectors, water systems and fertilizer programs.
Even repetitive production work becomes more meaningful when students understand the decisions behind it. Rather than only teaching a student to stick a poinsettia cutting, a grower can explain where the cutting fits in the production schedule, what happens during rooting, when the crop will be transplanted, what to watch for and why the finished-crop date matters. The work is not eliminated; it becomes learning.
The relationship also offers a recruiting opportunity. A student might first meet a company as a sophomore taking horticulture classes, visit its greenhouse as a junior, work with a grower or spend a summer with the team, then continue developing skills in the school greenhouse during senior year. At graduation, that young person should already see a real career path in horticulture.
A recruiting relationship, not a rescue
College may remain the right next step for many students, and Neese says it should be encouraged when it is. But for students who cannot attend, do not want to attend or, like him, know they want to get started, there should be another respected path into the profession. An 18-year-old with several years of vocational horticulture, meaningful commercial exposure and mentorship from experienced growers should not be viewed simply as unskilled labor. That person is a young horticulturist at the beginning of a career.
Schools cannot solve the industry’s workforce challenges alone, and commercial growers cannot solve vocational education alone. But between those worlds, Neese sees an opportunity. The industry can keep attending career fairs, posting openings and wondering why applicants lack practical experience, or it can become involved earlier: find the local agricultural education or horticulture program, meet the teacher, walk through the school greenhouse, ask what is needed and offer knowledge rather than only old equipment and leftover plants.
He urges growers to invite students into their operations in February as well as June, let them scout, test EC, examine roots, see good crops and problem crops, make mistakes, ask questions, diagnose problems and understand the decisions behind a quality crop. When students come to work in summer, he says, do not just give them the job nobody else wants. Give them a reason to want that job someday.
Somewhere today, another teenager is walking into a greenhouse for the first time and could become an exceptional grower, IPM specialist, propagator, production manager or greenhouse owner. Pitts and Greene opened that door for Neese and changed his life’s direction. He never needed horticulture presented as a fallback if college did not work out. For him, horticulture was the opportunity. If the industry is genuinely concerned about where its next generation will come from, he concludes, it should stop waiting for someone else to produce them. The future may already be sitting in a high-school classroom; the task is to help it grow.
